Golf R vs APR stage 1 Quattro A3 2.0t

[brimway]

a true enthusiast wouldn't drive an audi

Your comment invites argument

[Finance_Analyst]

You do realise that most Audis/VWs share the same platform, right?

Hence what I said earlier - you buy a new Audi at an Audi/BMW/Mercedes Benz premium prices new, but you sell next time at VW prices.

The used car market does not seem to appreciate any 'value add' Audi does over VW products, as BMW and Mercedes have no 'cheap imitation' so Audi resale values are terrible relative to its German rivals. VW is the thinking man's Audi, Audi is for the person who wants the badge and kudos BMW and Mercedes drivers enjoy.

[andrew7]

Hence what I said earlier - you buy a new Audi at an Audi/BMW/Mercedes Benz premium prices new, but you sell next time at VW prices.

The used car market does not seem to appreciate any 'value add' Audi does over VW products, as BMW and Mercedes have no 'cheap imitation' so Audi resale values are terrible relative to its German rivals. VW is the thinking man's Audi, Audi is for the person who wants the badge and kudos BMW and Mercedes drivers enjoy.

^ this

[Finance_Analyst]

Your comment invites argument

I would love to see an enthusiast in a A1....

[brimway]

I would love to see an enthusiast in a A1....

How about an RS4?

[nat225]

and same pistons / hoses / brake components / etc... open up the bonnet / look under the car / take off the wheels and look closer on the brakes / drivetrain parts... you will see both audi and vw logos on many parts.

You do realise that most Audis/VWs share the same platform, right?

[Finance_Analyst]

How about an RS4?

maybe but still a 4 door??? RS5 not as well received as M3 or C63 in general. R8 had its time in the sun from 07-09 (modern day Honda NSX - great car, underrated many) but the real enthusiasts still prefer the 911 Carrera I say, although a few may be real estate agents getting around town in them.

[MrGTIandRfan]

Would you guys 'step up' from a GTI to a slightly older S3 if the change over isn't much?

[DNA Tuning]

I think I would - ask yourself if you would upgrade from a GTI to an R and if the answers is Yes, then you should get the S3. It does lack the revised/improved Haldex AWD but unless you are a track junkie you'd be hard pressed to notice any difference.

I think Audis do tend to look modern for longer than their equivalent VW generation counterparts in general; if you look at the Mk V Golf for instance, the A3 already looked newer and they still haven't changed the styling much. Just my opinion anyway. Also they are built in Germany, so the general quality of the assembly will be more consistent, but I believe Mk 6's are also built in Germany now?

[SilvrFoxX]

you are taking the piss right..?

[Finance_Analyst]

as long as the first owner of an Audi took a bath on depreciation, maybe.... That way, I bought an S3 for a GTI price! But not if the S3 has heaps of kms, is thrashed and is a 3dr (as 3drs have even worse resale value).

Like for like, a 135i does sell for a more in the used car market than an S3, despite costing the same new.

[Njay]

I would prefer a golf r over a s3 just cause people think. Your wealthier just cause you drove an audi

[brimway]

maybe but still a 4 door??? RS5 not as well received as M3 or C63 in general. R8 had its time in the sun from 07-09 (modern day Honda NSX - great car, underrated many) but the real enthusiasts still prefer the 911 Carrera I say, although a few may be real estate agents getting around town in them.

I don't follow your logic, maybe because I am not an accountant. You say that a "true enthusiast wouldn't drive an Audi", but you concede that one may drive an RS4 although it has four doors???

You lost me

[SilvrFoxX]

Don't feel too bad, an Accountant and an enthusiast are mutually exclusive.. never the twain shall meet

[brimway]

Don't feel too bad, an Accountant and an enthusiast are mutually exclusive.. never the twain shall meet

Your posts never fail to give me a giggle, thanks