I don't think anyone complained about the Michelins, I assumed they were probably just more expensive to OEM fit. I think the PS3s would be anybodies best choice, it just comes down to being willing to fork out the money for them. Seeing as they so far have done double the milage it looks like pricewise you would still be ahead.
Above Forum Ad
Collapse
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
New tyres
Collapse
X
-
Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 2, better than the previous version I had on and way better than the Dunlops it came on.
The Asymmetric 2 have much better grip for accelerating and braking wet and dry and the same with cornering.
And I believe they are quite a bit quieter.
Forgot to add I've had both the Goodyear sets in 233/40 x 18 on the factory wheels of my pre facelift Octavia VRS.
Comment
-
I looked long and hard at the GY Eagle Asymetric2, and the Michelin PS3 before buying my last set. The Good Years are, on paper at least, every bit as good as the PS3 - even outrating them in a couple of comparrison tests - and at least $50 a corner cheaper. I opted for the PS3 only because it was a known quantity. I couldn't find anyone that actually had the Good Years to be able to get first hand accounts of their grip, wear, and noise level.Originally posted by pwcar View PostGoodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 2, better than the previous version I had on and way better than the Dunlops it came on.
The Asymmetric 2 have much better grip for accelerating and braking wet and dry and the same with cornering.
And I believe they are quite a bit quieter.
Forgot to add I've had both the Goodyear sets in 233/40 x 18 on the factory wheels of my pre facelift Octavia VRS.
For what it's worth, while Continental is making tyres in the USA, Romania, and South Africa the Good Year Eagle A2's are made in Germany.Last edited by BottomScratcher; 30-10-2013, 09:39 AM.
Comment
-
And how have you found the PS3s?
They are number one on my list at this point for next set in the next few months.2011 Skoda Octavia vRS TDI DSG wagon|Revo Stage 1|Race Blue|Leather|Dynamic Xenons w 6000K|9w7 BT|THA475 Amp+active sub|Whiteline ALK|RVC|
2009 R36 wagon|Biscay Blue|RVC|Tailgate|ECU and DSG tune|LED DRL/Indicators|3D colour cluster|Quad LED tail rings|Climatronics upgrade|Dynaudio retrofit|B7 RLine Flat Steering Wheel|3AA CCM|TPMS Direct|B7 Adaptive Cruise with Front Assist|Discover Media retrofit|PLA 2.0|Lane Assist|BCM retrofit|High Beam Assist|DQ500
Comment
-
I have the AS2's on my vRS. Damn good tyre, they're a little noisy on poor surfaces (so most of Victoria's roads) but they grip like no tomorrow both in the dry and in the wet.Originally posted by BottomScratcher View PostI looked long and hard at the GY Eagle Asymetric2, and the Michelin PS3 before buying my last set. The Good Years are, on paper at least, every bit as good as the PS3 - even outrating them in a couple of comparrison tests - and at least $50 a corner cheaper. I opted for the PS3 only because it was a known quantity. I couldn't find anyone that actually had the Good Years to be able to get first hand accounts of their grip, wear, and noise level.
For what it's worth, while Continental is making tyres in the USA, Romania, and South Africa the Good Year Eagle A2's are made in Germany.
Can't fault them. Wear I can't comment on as I've only done 3k since I bought it.
Comment
-
I honestly can't fault them. My hard driving days are behind me, but that said, I like to have a bit of fun on a bendy road. I had ContiSport Contact 2's fitted when I bought the car new. They were noisy, getting much louder when they wore down, and I got about 32K out of them, which I thought was pretty poor for the kind of driving I mostly do.Originally posted by kamold View PostAnd how have you found the PS3s?
They are number one on my list at this point for next set in the next few months.
I haven't done any measurements, but after 11K on the Michelin's they appear as new. I had an alignment done at Spinning Wheels (great tech) last Nov, and the shoulders on the PS3's are showing no signs of feathering at all. Given the cost of rubber these days I keep an eye on the pressures. The factory specs are rubbish. Far too low for all of our small tight roundabouts. I run 38 all round in town, and adjust for load and speed on trips - generally 40 all round for a medium load up/down the highway.
Road noise is less than the Conti's, but that's not saying a great deal. and as you know, I've got a wagon, so it's a bit drummy anyhow. When I first test drove an RS I was trying to get a sense of the noise levels, and until then had not consciously realised just many times the road surface changes every few hundred metres. As far as handling goes, what can I say, I point the wheel where I want it to go and the car goes there - dry or wet. I haven't had to brake hard in the wet, but as I said, I really can't fault the PS3, ..... but I'm still very curious about the GY Eagle A2A.
Comment
-
I'm still curious what the PS3s cost at Costco, they are forever doing sales on them. I put them on our 2006 Mazda 6 a few years back and they were half the price of the size the Skoda needs and not a great deal smaller. My wife found them better than the stock Bridgestones, but anything was better than those. We are now almost up to 60k on our OE Michelin PE2s with perfect even wear and still plenty left on them.
Comment
-
Thanks for the feedback. I'll be interested to see how they wear. As I said to kamold, I was surprised at how often road surfaces change, so a tyre can only be as quiet as the surface will allow, and some surfaces are so coarse as to not make any difference what tyres you've got. Oh, there will be a difference, but if it's only a difference between 79 and 82db (hearing protection is advised over 85db) then it doesn't matter. Loud is still loud.Originally posted by rjg View PostI have the AS2's on my vRS. Damn good tyre, they're a little noisy on poor surfaces (so most of Victoria's roads) but they grip like no tomorrow both in the dry and in the wet.
Can't fault them. Wear I can't comment on as I've only done 3k since I bought it.
I forgot to mention to kamold that the PS3's are more comfortable than the Conti's. They seem to absorb more of the bumps without any of the jarring through the steering wheel that I felt with the Contis. And that is running them at considerably higher than recommended pressures.
Comment
-
Thanks for the feedback.
I've mentioned it before somewhere, but I had PS2s on my previous car, the A3. They were perfectly serviceable at 60k when I sold the car. Have 45k on the CS2s on the RS now, rears are pretty worn but fronts have a few mm before the tread wear indicators, so I'll keep them going as long as I can. The rears (were the fronts) show wear on the shoulders which is pretty standard, when I get new rubber I'm also going to get the ALK installed and a good alignment done so there will be more than one change than just going from old to new tyres.
FWIW, I run 38-39 on the front and 40-42 on the rear depending on load. Sure its slightly firmer but I think worth it for wear. Agree that the placard recommended pressures seem a bit low.Last edited by kamold; 30-10-2013, 11:29 AM.2011 Skoda Octavia vRS TDI DSG wagon|Revo Stage 1|Race Blue|Leather|Dynamic Xenons w 6000K|9w7 BT|THA475 Amp+active sub|Whiteline ALK|RVC|
2009 R36 wagon|Biscay Blue|RVC|Tailgate|ECU and DSG tune|LED DRL/Indicators|3D colour cluster|Quad LED tail rings|Climatronics upgrade|Dynaudio retrofit|B7 RLine Flat Steering Wheel|3AA CCM|TPMS Direct|B7 Adaptive Cruise with Front Assist|Discover Media retrofit|PLA 2.0|Lane Assist|BCM retrofit|High Beam Assist|DQ500
Comment
-
There was all sorts of manufacturer BS about their "new" tyres a while back. The PS2 and Good Year Eagle F1 Asymetric just to name a couple were good tyres that did not meet the then newly introduced EU standards with regard to the exposure of plant workers to carcogenic gases given off during the manunufaturing process, so the "new" Asymetric2 and the PS3 are basically the same tyres as their predecessors made to the new EU standards.Originally posted by kamold View PostThanks for the feedback.
I've mentioned it before somewhere, but I had PS2s on my previous car, the A3. They were perfectly serviceable at 60k when I sold the car.
Comment
-
-
I'm still unconvinced as to the benefit, or not, of ALK's, but whatever floats your boat. I don't know if you've had an alignment since you bought your car, but our cars are notorious for being landed here ex-factory with too much positve rear camber, and too much toe out on the fronts. Because I was running the recommended pressures for too long prior to getting a good alignment done is mainly why I had to bin the Conti Contact2's. I think it was more like 37K than the 32K I mentioned earlier. The tread centres and insides were OK, but the outer shoulders were scrubbed out big time.Originally posted by kamold View PostThe rears (were the fronts) show wear on the shoulders which is pretty standard, when I get new rubber I'm also going to get the ALK installed and a good alignment done so there will be more than one change than just going from old to new tyres.
Point is that when getting a precision alignment a good tech who can do more than just set it up to what the spec sheet says, which is what most places do, is the key to the "precision" bit. A good tech will ask what pressures you run, "read" your tyre wear then tell you why your tyres are wearing the way they are and what he can do to correct it to get maximum benefit and wear out of your new expensive rubber - all before the car goes on the hoist. It may not be convenient for you location wise, but Spinning Wheels at Waterloo has just such a guy working there. The pricing is very reasonable. My last one was $119, which is standard for checking and straightforward corrections. The more corrections that need doing then the more the cost, but unless there is a major issue, one set of corrections should see you done. I won't take my car anywhere else, and I live about 5 minutes away from Heasman's.
Comment
-
Good advice. I'm prepared to travel for quality work, thanks for the tip.
Sent from my HTC One using Tapatalk2011 Skoda Octavia vRS TDI DSG wagon|Revo Stage 1|Race Blue|Leather|Dynamic Xenons w 6000K|9w7 BT|THA475 Amp+active sub|Whiteline ALK|RVC|
2009 R36 wagon|Biscay Blue|RVC|Tailgate|ECU and DSG tune|LED DRL/Indicators|3D colour cluster|Quad LED tail rings|Climatronics upgrade|Dynaudio retrofit|B7 RLine Flat Steering Wheel|3AA CCM|TPMS Direct|B7 Adaptive Cruise with Front Assist|Discover Media retrofit|PLA 2.0|Lane Assist|BCM retrofit|High Beam Assist|DQ500
Comment
-
2025 - Below Forum
Collapse

Comment