Above Forum Ad

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

First Golf R 420 hp (315kw) build in the world - Australian exclusive!

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #46
    Guy_H, I have some questions about various APR upgrades for the Golf R and thought I may as well ask here so that other people can find and refer to the information if needed.

    I'm considering doing a Stage II upgrade, but I'd like to leave my options open for a future migration to Stage III if possible.

    Downpipe:
    On the 2.0T STG III - S3, TTS, R page, it mentions that a Stage 3 S3/TTS/GOLF R - Divorced Downpipe is required but not included. The cost is $2495 but it doesn't mention whether the high-flow cat and adaptor is included in that price as it is with the "regular APR downpipe".

    Can the Stage III downpipe be used with a Stage II upgrade, or is it only applicable for the Stage III kits?
    Also, does the S3 downpipe and highflow cat fit on the R?

    Intake:
    Is there any advantage to the Stage II Carbonio intake over the Stage I intake? From the looks of things, the stock R piping looks to be quite large and restriction free as it is, and obviously if I went to the Stage III kit later, the Stage II pipe would be discarded anyway.

    As a side question to this, the R's engine cover looks to be substantially larger than the GTI's engine cover. It appears that even the intake pipes are covered by a single plastic piece. Can the engine cover still be installed if a Carbonio Stage I or Stage II intake is installed?

    Intercooler:
    You've stated that the R's intercooler is smaller than the S3's intercooler. Does this mean the R's intercooler is the one used in the Pirelli?
    The APR Intercooler seems like a good option if this is the case. I notice that it's designed to connect to the OEM pipes.

    There are several forum members (including APR customers) who have mentioned that the OEM pipes are actually a cause of restriction and that changing them even without changing the intercooler can equate to a 3 to 5kw improvement atw. It has been recommended to me to use these two products:
    Neuspeed HI-FLO Air Charge Pipe
    Neuspeed HI-FLO Turbo Discharge Conversion

    What is your opinion on this topic? Do you believe that replacing the OEM pipes to and from the intercooler is worthwhile, and if so, which products do you use?


    Thanks in advance

    Comment


    • #47
      So this car has been dynoed at 315KW yes?or No?
      Prove it.

      I smell BS,Has the engine been apart or is it ECU tuning plus add on parts?

      To me this thread is just a "look at me,see how much $$ bolt on goodies I can spend"

      I wish people on this forum would wake up and smell the Bu...it

      Comment


      • #48
        Originally posted by R1 Crasher View Post
        So this car has been dynoed at 315KW yes?or No?
        Prove it.

        I smell BS,Has the engine been apart or is it ECU tuning plus add on parts?

        To me this thread is just a "look at me,see how much $$ bolt on goodies I can spend"

        I wish people on this forum would wake up and smell the Bu...it
        LOL, you're right. This is a massive e-penis thread and its all bull****.....

        Comment


        • #49
          Originally posted by R1 Crasher View Post
          So this car has been dynoed at 315KW yes?or No?
          Prove it.

          I smell BS,Has the engine been apart or is it ECU tuning plus add on parts?

          To me this thread is just a "look at me,see how much $$ bolt on goodies I can spend"

          I wish people on this forum would wake up and smell the Bu...it
          You may be interested to see this article from Motor Magazine on the Audi S3 from which all these parts have been taken.
          Also you may not know Guy_H, but "in real life" he is known as Guy Harding, owner of Harding Performance who distribute and install aftermarket performance upgrades from many companies, including APR, for many brands of cars, VW being one of them.

          Now obviously, if you know anything about cars, placing this on a regular dyno won't show 315KW, as that's a flywheel figure (which are much more accurate and consistent) rather than a rolling road "at the wheels" figure, which are very inconsistent even from day to day, let alone dyno to dyno.

          Since the S3 that all these parts came from is such a well known car, many of us have seen that even in the "test that everything is working" rolling-road dyno run during its initial build it did 250.1kw atw. There is also many occasions after this that the same car did rolling-road dyno runs as it travelled to events up and down the east coast as part of the APR promotional activities (I can't be bothered looking up the figures for each of these)

          So before you go around throwing your own "BS", why don't you first do the slightest bit of research. As for Guy_H, he doesn't need to prove his credibility. You do!

          Comment


          • #50
            Originally posted by coreying View Post
            You may be interested to see this article from Motor Magazine on the Audi S3 from which all these parts have been taken.
            Also you may not know Guy_H, but "in real life" he is known as Guy Harding, owner of Harding Performance who distribute and install aftermarket performance upgrades from many companies, including APR, for many brands of cars, VW being one of them.

            Now obviously, if you know anything about cars, placing this on a regular dyno won't show 315KW, as that's a flywheel figure (which are much more accurate and consistent) rather than a rolling road "at the wheels" figure, which are very inconsistent even from day to day, let alone dyno to dyno.

            Since the S3 that all these parts came from is such a well known car, many of us have seen that even in the "test that everything is working" rolling-road dyno run during its initial build it did 250.1kw atw. There is also many occasions after this that the same car did rolling-road dyno runs as it travelled to events up and down the east coast as part of the APR promotional activities (I can't be bothered looking up the figures for each of these)

            So before you go around throwing your own "BS", why don't you first do the slightest bit of research. As for Guy_H, he doesn't need to prove his credibility. You do!

            Exactly.These Stage 3 cars have been dyno'ed on numerous occasions and always produce around 250 kw atw.
            I have done enough kilometres in Guy's cars [and others] to vouch for their performance.
            Love these people who come on Forums from nowhere and bag things without doing any research-talk about zero credibility!

            Comment


            • #51
              Originally posted by coreying View Post
              Guy_H, I have some questions about various APR upgrades for the Golf R and thought I may as well ask here so that other people can find and refer to the information if needed.

              I'm considering doing a Stage II upgrade, but I'd like to leave my options open for a future migration to Stage III if possible.

              Downpipe:
              On the 2.0T STG III - S3, TTS, R page, it mentions that a Stage 3 S3/TTS/GOLF R - Divorced Downpipe is required but not included. The cost is $2495 but it doesn't mention whether the high-flow cat and adaptor is included in that price as it is with the "regular APR downpipe".

              Can the Stage III downpipe be used with a Stage II upgrade, or is it only applicable for the Stage III kits?
              Also, does the S3 downpipe and highflow cat fit on the R?

              Intake:
              Is there any advantage to the Stage II Carbonio intake over the Stage I intake? From the looks of things, the stock R piping looks to be quite large and restriction free as it is, and obviously if I went to the Stage III kit later, the Stage II pipe would be discarded anyway.

              As a side question to this, the R's engine cover looks to be substantially larger than the GTI's engine cover. It appears that even the intake pipes are covered by a single plastic piece. Can the engine cover still be installed if a Carbonio Stage I or Stage II intake is installed?

              Intercooler:
              You've stated that the R's intercooler is smaller than the S3's intercooler. Does this mean the R's intercooler is the one used in the Pirelli?
              The APR Intercooler seems like a good option if this is the case. I notice that it's designed to connect to the OEM pipes.

              There are several forum members (including APR customers) who have mentioned that the OEM pipes are actually a cause of restriction and that changing them even without changing the intercooler can equate to a 3 to 5kw improvement atw. It has been recommended to me to use these two products:
              Neuspeed HI-FLO Air Charge Pipe
              Neuspeed HI-FLO Turbo Discharge Conversion

              What is your opinion on this topic? Do you believe that replacing the OEM pipes to and from the intercooler is worthwhile, and if so, which products do you use?


              Thanks in advance
              Downpipe: $2495 includes the full three sections - divorced downpipe / Cat section / Adapter to catback. If you go to Stage 3 & have the K04 front section we will include it as a trade in with your kit!

              Intake: What we have done is modify the water lines & intake pipe a little so we can use the TSI intake head & filter in this case. I understand that this will be available as a production part in the future.

              The airboxes are identical - S3 Golf V & Golf R, so no size difference there.

              Stage 2 pipe is only for the Golf 6 GTI cam chain motor, not applicable (at this stage) for the FSI motor (golf R).

              Intercooler: - certainly our car only has the stock GTI plastic tanked intercooler. The Pirelli & S3 ran an alloy tanked version (both slightly different) so it seems that the R is hobbled from this point slightly. Cold air is good air!

              The "other pipes" - have not seen any data on testing - I have seen bench flow testing and there was no increase in flow (and no increase in diameter through the entire pipe - this was MKV pipes) (really because there is no restriction, especially on the pressure side). I would love to see some data that shows what a difference they make!
              sigpic

              Comment


              • #52
                Originally posted by Guy_H
                Yes it has, it will be independently tested by a magazine on an independent dyno in the near future (along with 30 other tuners cars), and same as all our stage 3 kits, you get the advertised power.

                No, engine has not been apart - the build thread is in the links. So yes its ECU tuning + add on parts.


                I don't know what your problem is but 90% of your threads are attacking APR, me or anyone who uses the product.

                We sell & develop products for the Golf R, what better way is there to do that & test them apart from getting a car & doing it ourselves? We are not an internet shop that sells stuff & "hope" it fits.
                Good one Guy....

                This thread is an absolute bonus to all of us out there who want to see the score on the board as far as your cars are concerned..
                What better way than to your results after bolt on's and remaps!

                Keep up the good work!

                Next for me the divorced downpipe and intake, and perhaps the intercooler upgrade.
                Last edited by Fab_R; 12-07-2010, 01:21 PM.

                Comment


                • #53
                  right... everyone got that out of their systems???!?!?!?!

                  thread cleaned up. Please, if you want round two of "fanboys vs. Tim" take it to the PM system.

                  keep it on the black stuff fella's
                  VW: it aint just a car, its a way of life
                  There are few things more satisfying in life than finding a solution to a problem and implementing it
                  My Blog: tinkererstales.blogspot.com.au

                  Comment


                  • #54
                    Scirocco R - Candy White / DSG / Panoramic Roof / RNS510
                    Mods - HPA ECU & DSG Stage 2 / VWR Racing Intake / Akrapovic Slip-On Titanium Tips / Milltek DP / HPA Mounts / Superpro LCA / H&R Sport Springs / VMR V710 19x8.5 / Michelin PSS 255-35

                    Comment


                    • #55
                      Thanks Golfman, really enjoying this thread and be excellent to see the results. Top notch work Guy.
                      Audi S3-White Lightning

                      Comment


                      • #56
                        Originally posted by GoLfMan View Post
                        right... everyone got that out of their systems???!?!?!?!
                        Originally posted by ktrianta View Post
                        The only way we can possibly move forward is to get half price stage 1 tunes for our R's

                        Comment


                        • #57
                          +1...+1...+1...

                          damn 10 character minimum
                          Scirocco R - Candy White / DSG / Panoramic Roof / RNS510
                          Mods - HPA ECU & DSG Stage 2 / VWR Racing Intake / Akrapovic Slip-On Titanium Tips / Milltek DP / HPA Mounts / Superpro LCA / H&R Sport Springs / VMR V710 19x8.5 / Michelin PSS 255-35

                          Comment


                          • #58
                            WTF, I havent logged on in a while..... that thing is freakin amazing...Leave it to Guy to do the serious biz...nice to see the Alcons on there. Im looking at trading in my Pirelli on one of these bad boys. My question to Guy or anyone in the know over there is
                            A. when we go this route with tuning the car, ie 315kw at the motor. what is the cost factor of building up a manual box in the R, over a DSG.? Because of the fact that you can put in a twin plate clutch etc and be rest assured that launching the car at the rack all day is not giving you the "i wonder how bad that was vibe".!.
                            Having a DSG now and having come from a manual Id be happy with either.
                            But I guess I just wonder over the long run which is best, I had a buddy with a heavy twin in his car and I loved the fact that you could barely push the pedal in but when you stepped off..it bit very hard.... lol, just the effect Id like in an R.
                            I know its busy over there but please if you get a chance let us know how any clutch \ gearbox improvements go.
                            MY 12.5 Golf R
                            09 Pirelli GTI sold
                            09 A6 2.0T

                            Comment


                            • #59
                              Stupid question, I assume the latest version of the DSG is no longer limited to handle 350nm of torque?
                              Volvo S60 RD T6

                              Comment


                              • #60
                                Originally posted by thezoneR32 View Post
                                Stupid question, I assume the latest version of the DSG is no longer limited to handle 350nm of torque?
                                Not sure? It was an extremely conservative torque limit though.. typically German. Many MKV's run more than that with no issue as we know.


                                APR S2/Whiteline/H&R/Enkei/Carbonio/13.68@101/Winton-1:44.52

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X