Above Forum Ad

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

pulled over by a police car...

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #16
    Originally posted by maca View Post
    Let us know. I have them on the front (to protect my PPQ's from bugs/stones etc).
    PPQ say not to use any covers on their plates or the warranty is invalid. I think they say this so we leave them unprotected and have to replace them $$$ when they get damaged as I've had mine since 1997 and always had the altrex plate frames on them and they still look like new.

    Just thought it could've been jealousy or something. Copper needs to find something constructive to do.
    Or he was doing his job, given that no-one knows exactly what transpired between the OP and the police or if the police had reports of a car matching the OP's involved in something or a car that matched the OP's was stolen earlier or if the number plate caught a bad angle and flashed the officer. Easy to try and guess that it was for some untoward reason he pulled the OP over but he would have had his reasons.
    website: www.my-gti.com

    Comment


    • #17
      If the dealer is fitting unroadworthy components to a brand new car then IT IS their responsibility.
      2010 Mk VI GTI-Red/Manual/Detroits/Park assist/Leather/MDI/Sunroof/Bi-Xenons/Chassis Control/Elec Driver's seat/5 Door/Tint
      2009 Triumph Street Triple R Matte Blazing Orange
      1971 Mini Clubman GT

      Comment


      • #18
        Originally posted by Brian View Post
        Sorry here guys, but YOU alone are responsible for your vehicles condition.
        Much the same as if your passenger was not wearing a seat belt - YOU cop the fine.
        I'd check it out with my local DMV or whatever its called in your state to get a definitive answer.
        I also have these number plate covers and will check it out for QLD conditions ASAP
        Cheers,
        Brian
        I think VW would have to take some of the blame if your cars is defected for something it came new with!

        Oh and if the passenger is over 18 they get the fine, not the driver!

        Stoney!
        6 Sp Manual 118 TSi
        Colour: United Grey
        Build Date: August 09 Delivery Date: 16th Oct 09
        ODO at last fill: 2555km
        Avg Fuel Cons at last fill: 8.6

        Comment


        • #19
          Originally posted by Stoney! View Post
          I think VW would have to take some of the blame if your cars is defected for something it came new with!

          Oh and if the passenger is over 18 they get the fine, not the driver!

          Stoney!
          Not in QLD, the driver gets fined if the anyone in the car is not wearing a seatbelt.
          2002 Volkswagen Bora V5 - 2007 Mazda 3 GT - 1998 Ford Contour Sport - 2010 Volkswagen Jetta 2.0T - 2013 Volkswagen Passat 130TDI - 2015 Ford Escape 1.5 - 2016 Subaru WRX - 2018 Volkswagen Golf R Wolfsburg Wagon

          Comment


          • #20
            Originally posted by irossiter View Post
            If the dealer is fitting unroadworthy components to a brand new car then IT IS their responsibility.
            No it's not. I find it hard to believe that so many people know so little about the law with regards to the operation of a motor vehicle.

            The driver alone is responsible for making sure his car is roadworthy before he drives it. It doesn't matter if the car is yours, a friends, a rental or a work car. If you drive it and the car is found to be unroadworthy it's your responsibility.
            website: www.my-gti.com

            Comment


            • #21
              From Qld transport web site
              VHow can I tell if my number plates are legible?

              Legally, the characters on the number plate must be visible from 20 metres (m) away at any point within an arc of 45 degrees from the surface of the plate, above or to either side of the vehicle. Number plates must be permanently attached to a vehicle so that when it is on level ground the plates are upright, horizontal, and not more than 1.3 m above the ground.

              Over time, exhaust fumes, chemicals, stones, the sun, and general wear and tear can damage your plates and make them hard to read. So it is a good idea to check their condition especially if you have older plates.

              Some plates are obviously deteriorated or damaged. Others may look okay but are hard to read from a distance or at night. Standard plates are guaranteed for 10 years.

              You could be fined up to A$320 for not replacing your old or illegible plates.

              Police and transport inspectors regularly check the condition of number plates. It's your responsibility to ensure your plates are in a legible condition and to replace them or clean them if they're not.


              Last updated 07 April 2010
              Doesn't mention plate covers, but I suspect if you got an arseh*le of a cop, then they may be able to claim illegibility in some reflected light
              I'm not going to sweat it.
              Brian
              Current drive:2016 Golf GTI 40 Years in Pure White

              Comment


              • #22
                Originally posted by Maverick View Post
                No it's not. I find it hard to believe that so many people know so little about the law with regards to the operation of a motor vehicle.

                The driver alone is responsible for making sure his car is roadworthy before he drives it. It doesn't matter if the car is yours, a friends, a rental or a work car. If you drive it and the car is found to be unroadworthy it's your responsibility.
                Well said Maverick. I too am astounded by the ignorance of some drivers WRT their obligations under the law.
                Brian
                Current drive:2016 Golf GTI 40 Years in Pure White

                Comment


                • #23
                  Originally posted by Brian View Post
                  From Qld transport web site


                  Doesn't mention plate covers, but I suspect if you got an arseh*le of a cop, then they may be able to claim illegibility in some reflected light
                  I'm not going to sweat it.
                  Brian
                  Altrex who are one of the major manufacturers say

                  "Are they legal?
                  Yes. At Altrex we have manufactured and distributed number plate protectors for over 15 years in Australia. They are legal in all states and do not contravene the regulations laid down in the Motor Traffic Regulations in any state or territory. The regulations state that a number plate cover must not cause the letters or numbers on a number plate to be obscured in any way. Provided your number plate protector is clean and does not obscure your plate’s letters or numbers in any way, your Altrex Number Plate Protector is legal.

                  Neither the lined or unlined Altrex Number Plate Protectors prevent the letters or numbers from being clearly seen from a long distance (in excess of 20m which is the legal requirement). None of our covers are tinted. All Altrex covers are flat across the entire surface. They do not contain any reflective material nor do they have any characteristics which impede radar or speed cameras.

                  If you have any questions about this issue please do not hesitate to contact us. We can supply copies of all approvals from the police and motor transport relevant authorities on request."

                  Altrex - FAQ for our high quality automotive accessories

                  It's entirely possible that the OP's number plate frames are marginal with respect to the law.
                  website: www.my-gti.com

                  Comment


                  • #24
                    Originally posted by Maverick View Post
                    Altrex who are one of the major manufacturers say

                    "Are they legal?
                    Yes. At Altrex we have manufactured and distributed number plate protectors for over 15 years in Australia. They are legal in all states and do not contravene the regulations laid down in the Motor Traffic Regulations in any state or territory. The regulations state that a number plate cover must not cause the letters or numbers on a number plate to be obscured in any way. Provided your number plate protector is clean and does not obscure your plate’s letters or numbers in any way, your Altrex Number Plate Protector is legal.

                    Neither the lined or unlined Altrex Number Plate Protectors prevent the letters or numbers from being clearly seen from a long distance (in excess of 20m which is the legal requirement). None of our covers are tinted. All Altrex covers are flat across the entire surface. They do not contain any reflective material nor do they have any characteristics which impede radar or speed cameras.

                    If you have any questions about this issue please do not hesitate to contact us. We can supply copies of all approvals from the police and motor transport relevant authorities on request."

                    Altrex - FAQ for our high quality automotive accessories

                    It's entirely possible that the OP's number plate frames are marginal with respect to the law.
                    Long story short - the cop was a douche.
                    2002 Volkswagen Bora V5 - 2007 Mazda 3 GT - 1998 Ford Contour Sport - 2010 Volkswagen Jetta 2.0T - 2013 Volkswagen Passat 130TDI - 2015 Ford Escape 1.5 - 2016 Subaru WRX - 2018 Volkswagen Golf R Wolfsburg Wagon

                    Comment


                    • #25
                      Originally posted by maca View Post
                      Long story short - the cop was a douche.
                      I didn't know you were there to see exactly what transpired!
                      website: www.my-gti.com

                      Comment


                      • #26
                        Originally posted by Maverick View Post
                        I didn't know you were there to see exactly what transpired!
                        I'm going by OP's reconstruction.
                        2002 Volkswagen Bora V5 - 2007 Mazda 3 GT - 1998 Ford Contour Sport - 2010 Volkswagen Jetta 2.0T - 2013 Volkswagen Passat 130TDI - 2015 Ford Escape 1.5 - 2016 Subaru WRX - 2018 Volkswagen Golf R Wolfsburg Wagon

                        Comment


                        • #27
                          Originally posted by irossiter View Post
                          that is reflected in how much cheaper it is to insure a GTI compared to a rice rocket.
                          I've never tried to insure anything made of rice, but my insurance sure isn't what I'd call 'cheap'

                          Originally posted by Stoney! View Post
                          Oh and if the passenger is over 18 they get the fine, not the driver!
                          Then why do they have ads all over the radio on double-demerit weekends saying "If you and just 1 passenger aren't wearing seatbelts - you'll lose your licence!" ???


                          @Maverick - while I agree with you in general (to an extent - at most times, in most threads) you certainly do make me feel less guilty about all the times someone has called me 'harsh' or a 'nazi'
                          VW Driver

                          Comment


                          • #28
                            Morally but not Legally responsible

                            Originally posted by Maverick View Post
                            How is the dealer responsible? If he has a ticket issued it'll be to him not the dealer and he can take it to court and see what a judge has to say but at the end of the day it's his car and he's responsible for it.
                            Have to agree with Maverick. Dealer may be morally responsible for selling you "unroadworthy number plate covers" but you are driving it, you are the one legally responsible for the condition of the car you were driving and you get the ticket if it eventuates.

                            Cop did the right thing in giving the OP a warning. If the plate covers make the plate more difficult or impossible to read in certain conditions he has probably saved the OP a fine imposed by a more zealous or less understanding cop.

                            Dealer has actually sold you a car that will easily break all our speed limits but I don't think a naughty driver would be able to sheet the responsibility for the speeding ticket back to the selling dealer.

                            Silly argument I know but no sillier than advising the OP not to worry as it would be the dealer's responsibility if he got a ticket for non compliant number plate covers.
                            You know you are getting old when you cancel your order for a 3.6 CC and buy an Icelandic Gray TDI CC instead.

                            Comment


                            • #29
                              Originally posted by Stoney! View Post
                              Oh and if the passenger is over 18 they get the fine, not the driver!
                              Originally posted by maca View Post
                              Not in QLD, the driver gets fined if the anyone in the car is not wearing a seatbelt.
                              Guys, I just want to confirm that in NSW, if ANYONE in your car does not have a seatbelt on, regardless of age, THE DRIVER will receive the fine and Demerit points.

                              A single person in the car without a seatbelt means 3 Demerit points + $253 fine. Two people in the car means 6 Demerit points + $506 fine. On a double Demerit poitns weekend, this means INSTANT LOSS OF LICENCE! It doesn't matter which two people either (could be driver + passenger, could be two passengers).

                              Stoney, you're in NSW so you should know better

                              Please refer to this RTA page on Seat Belt penalties.

                              As maca has stated, QLD is the same way. I would be surprised if other states aren't also the same.

                              Comment


                              • #30
                                Originally posted by McDub View Post
                                if you did get fined, your dealer would be responsible, i wouldn't worry about it.
                                call your dealer if it bothers you
                                You're responsible for ensuring the car is roadworthy once it's in your ownership. You'd not get very far using the dealership as the excuse.

                                Technically, a plate cover shouldn't be reflective as it may stop a safety camera (speed, red light, whatever) from getting a clear shot of your numberplate. There are (in theory) plate holders and even liquids that you apply to your regular plate holders that allow you to look at the plate normally, but reflect strong flashes of light, protecting you from cameras - but I've never actually seen if they work or not.

                                My guess is the cop's headlights flashed across your plate and he got a reflection he wasn't expecting. Safest thing to do would be to remove the plate cover.

                                Don't let it spoil your night - he was doing his job, and you didn't get fined. Some cops are not as nice as this one was, so it was really a good night for you.
                                Nothing to see here...

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X