Chips....a different approach

[Y2008]

Been reasearching the Polo GTI chipping options way before I even finalised my decision about the car but it just got to a certain point and stopped progressing. GIAC, APR, Otteinger or REVO? But the problem is that its very subjective and from what I've seen is that most peoples final decisions have been based on many factors other than how the chip performs (since they have very similar performance). So I thought of a few questions that I hope might help me in my quest.

Has anyone here tested more than one chip?
If yes, what were the differences (in your own opinion)?
Has anyone driven two cars chipped by different suppliers back to back?
If yes, what were your first thoughts?

[99gti]

Most of the big names will offer a free trial. I'd suggest getting in touch with the local outlets and asking for the trial and make your decision from there.

[Sharkie]

The chips from the different manufacturers all provide similar benefits for similar prices.

Base your decision on what else you want to do as some manufacturers offers other integrated and related products as well.

[Y2008]

well i have already narrowed it down to two and am planning on testing them back to back. The only reason im seeking other peoples experiences with trying more than one, is that im worried that my initial excitement about trying the product might skew my decision making ability and blind me to certain factors. I wanna hear what people thought of them so i know what to be looking for. Smoothness of power etc. I'm mainly comparing pros and cons between APR and REVO. And my comparison is only baised on price, and method of activation rather than performance or power.

I actually wanna know about the people who tried both, and what was their final decision between the two and what were their personal reasons to choose one over the other

[RhysQ]

you seem very very particular about this, almost to the point where it wouldn't matter what we say as its not enough for you to run off. i suggest the best and only thing you should do is get the free trials and let us know what you think of each, as you have obviously got certain points in your head you are looking for in each manufacturer.

just remember, there will be bias in everyones answer, no matter what they say.

seriously though, i don't believe there will be any cognitive dissonance from any of these manufacturers. the only problem you will have is trying to wipe the smile off your face.

correct me if i'm wrong, but aren't Oettinger and APR the exact same product, just different label?

Cheers,
Rhys

[Koz]

I believe that the best option would be a free trail comparison.

However,I personally believe the best chip hands down is Kettle. YUM!



Peace

Koz

[T Go]

seriously though, i don't believe there will be any cognitive dissonance from any of these manufacturers. the only problem you will have is trying to wipe the smile off your face.

Cheers,
Rhys

Congnitive Dissonance!
Best phrase I've heard in months.

[Timbo]

I wanna hear what people thought of them so i know what to be looking for.

"Search" is your friend Most people who get chipped post about their impressions and really don't want to type it all again each time a new owner asks this question

[tobes]

Congnitive Dissonance!
Best phrase I've heard in months.

Yup, someone is just heading back to uni after a break in their Pysch course

[evorobin]

seriously though, i don't believe there will be any cognitive dissonance from any of these manufacturers.

The Role of Cognitive Dissonance in Reducing Conflict

In spite of people's desire to avoid it, the proper use of cognitive dissonance can be a useful tool in overcoming conflict. Cognitive dissonance is a basic tool for education in general. Creating dissonance can induce behavior or attitude change. By creating cognitive dissonance, you force people to react. In other words, a child can be encouraged to learn by creating dissonance between what they think they know and what they actually do -- drawing attention to the fact that they know stealing is wrong even though they took a cookie, etc. The same idea can be used in adults. By introducing cognitive dissonance (pointing out the conflict between what people know and do), we can encourage a change in thought or action.

I'd be worried if they didn't but hey I'm not a lecturer...

[DaveMack]

The Role of Cognitive Dissonance in Reducing Conflict

In spite of people's desire to avoid it, the proper use of cognitive dissonance can be a useful tool in overcoming conflict. Cognitive dissonance is a basic tool for education in general. Creating dissonance can induce behavior or attitude change. By creating cognitive dissonance, you force people to react. In other words, a child can be encouraged to learn by creating dissonance between what they think they know and what they actually do -- drawing attention to the fact that they know stealing is wrong even though they took a cookie, etc. The same idea can be used in adults. By introducing cognitive dissonance (pointing out the conflict between what people know and do), we can encourage a change in thought or action.

I'd be worried if they didn't but hey I'm not a lecturer...

All the same, Robin ... thanks for sharing. (Now ... where's the yawn icon?)

Dave

[RhysQ]

cognitive dissonance is a broad topic......i was referring to it as a point of 'post-purchase dissonance' (the whole "i bought this, but hey, should i have bought that....dammit")....AKA cognitive dissonance.

so then, leaving the long words aside....let us know how your free trial goes (if you are going to get one that is)

Cheers,
Rhys

[Y2008]

thanks guys for the help I will get to it once i have some time. I'll try to get the trials back to back and will try my best to explain my experience with as much detail and as little bias as possible. I think i might let the car do another 1000ks just for things to smoothen up a bit. And thanks again guy.

[Revo Kev]

Hey guys, thought I should add some information in regards to trial software.
You might not be aware, but trial software is only a taster... it typically runs at 80% of the full software (if that) and doesn't always have the adjustability the full code does. It's certainly not a comparative tool.
The idea behind it was to expand the potential market; offer trial to people that would never consider 'tuning' their car!
So you're aware Revo offer a 30day money back on all software, and the software would be setup to suit your car, fuel quality and conditions.
Hope this helps.