Above Forum Ad

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Intercooler Physics Primer (and response to claims about forge unit)

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Intercooler Physics Primer (and response to claims about forge unit)

    Originally posted by Guy_H View Post
    I will try to get some time to post up the testing data - we did this to show to at least 5 of our customers that lost a significant amount of boost & power when swapping the stock intercooler to the Forge unit. We have flow bench testing data, dyno logs & road logs. But that's for another thread! Sorry, never tested the Seat one!
    I'd like to see this data.

    I have one, and I can testify right now that I did not loose a "significant" amount of boost & power.

    I can't speak for Guy, but honestly, the car industry is always slagging each others products. If you accept any vendor's appraisal of a product that they have a directly competing product for you're an idiot, pure and simple. Remember, this is the same APR that charge $3000aud for a turbo you can buy online (legitimate borg warner unit) for ~$1000 us.

    Heres the facts:

    1. Plautos's car is running a GT28RS, thats a much bigger turbo. Thats a lot more air, and an intercooler designed for a K03 is likely not suitable for the following reason:

    2. Air cannot be cooled unless it interacts (Via friction) with the intercooler. If there is no friction (eg, the intercooler flows HEAPS), it will not cool the air. The right intercooler is the one that provides the best trade-off in terms of restriction vs cooling ability.

    3. An intercooler that doesn't result in a loss of boost is not cooling the air. The boost does not 'magically' disappear... it goes down because the air is now denser (cooler air is more dense). The same amount of air comes out as what goes in. 'Boost Loss' through an intercooler is irrelevant.

    4. Its worth noting here that the MAP sensor is POST intercooler on the Polo - so any loss of boost pressure will be taken into account by the ECU; it will work the turbo harder to get the programmed boost. This will result in more overall air. I would have thought a tuner would understand that fact.


    I'm not saying the forge unit is the best one - it most likely isn't as its a turnflow. But to say it results in a 'significant loss of performance' is absolutely and utterly misleading.
    Last edited by xtturbo; 20-12-2010, 01:26 PM.

  • #2
    Where is that quote from? Please provide the link.

    It's not just car parts suppliers with axes to grind mate.

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by mikinoz View Post
      Where is that quote from? Please provide the link.

      It's not just car parts suppliers with axes to grind mate.


      No axe grinding here, just pointing out some basics...

      Comment


      • #4
        Your post is best discussed in the other thread in it's context. It can be discussed there.

        Comment


        • #5
          Have a look and see what Anthonys car made at the last dyno day ( little red devil) , his car runs a forge unit
          Cheers
          Jmac
          Alba European
          Service, Diagnostics and repairs. Mobile Diag available on request
          Audi/VW/Porsche Factory trained tech 25+ yrs exp
          For people who value experience call 0423965341

          Comment

          Working...
          X