Been going through the front suspension on the Golf, replacing worn bushes etc as needed, & I have run into a few issues while replacing the Strut Top Mounts / Bearings. Would really appreciate some advice from the experienced guys on here.
My golf has the earlier struts with the slotted nut that hold the top spring retainer in place. first issue was that the slotted nut was already loose on both struts when I went to dismantle them.


No real issue there ....but when I went to reassemble them I realised that they wouldn't tighten up because last time the struts where replaced (KYB struts) they had not put the spacer/washer on & so the nut would bottom out on the thread before it tightened up on the seat & bearing. No problem, just sourced a couple of suitable washers & away I went........ until.........
Once I tightened the slotted nuts I discovered that the top spring retainer was rubbing/binding on the metal part of the strut mount. Disassembled them again & found that there was already a fairly good wear ring on the spring retainers from where they had been rubbing before.

So I moved the washer from under the spring retainer & re-installed it between the spring retainer & the strut mount. As you can see the Bentley shows it under the spring retainer.

All was now good until I got to final assembly & lowered the golf back onto the ground.
Drivers side strut has pushed up much further though the strut housing than the passenger side. I would nearly say that its worse than the old worn one. Drivers side has about a 11-15mm gap, passenger side has 3-4mm gap.
I have no idea what is normal here but would consider the 3-4mm closer to the mark.
Drivers side:


Passenger side:

This is what the new strut mounts looked like as far as the height is concerned (not my photo though).

This is what the old ones are like, bearings completely fell apart when I pulled the struts out.


Both struts mounts appear to be seated roughly the into the strut housing in the body, it just looks like the drivers side strut mount has collapsed into itself already.
Yes I have taken it for a shakedown run to see if the passenger side would seat itself higher after the suspension was cycled a few times but made no difference.
Has the drivers side strut mount failed already??????????
Should I pull it off & try for warranty?
What is involved in changing over to the later style strut mounts? would I need to change the actual struts & springs or just the mounting hardware from the top of the spring onwards.
Sorry for the long post , but thought it might save a few questions going back & forth.
Hope you guys can help.......
Cheers
Brendan
My golf has the earlier struts with the slotted nut that hold the top spring retainer in place. first issue was that the slotted nut was already loose on both struts when I went to dismantle them.


No real issue there ....but when I went to reassemble them I realised that they wouldn't tighten up because last time the struts where replaced (KYB struts) they had not put the spacer/washer on & so the nut would bottom out on the thread before it tightened up on the seat & bearing. No problem, just sourced a couple of suitable washers & away I went........ until.........
Once I tightened the slotted nuts I discovered that the top spring retainer was rubbing/binding on the metal part of the strut mount. Disassembled them again & found that there was already a fairly good wear ring on the spring retainers from where they had been rubbing before.

So I moved the washer from under the spring retainer & re-installed it between the spring retainer & the strut mount. As you can see the Bentley shows it under the spring retainer.

All was now good until I got to final assembly & lowered the golf back onto the ground.
Drivers side strut has pushed up much further though the strut housing than the passenger side. I would nearly say that its worse than the old worn one. Drivers side has about a 11-15mm gap, passenger side has 3-4mm gap.
I have no idea what is normal here but would consider the 3-4mm closer to the mark.
Drivers side:


Passenger side:

This is what the new strut mounts looked like as far as the height is concerned (not my photo though).

This is what the old ones are like, bearings completely fell apart when I pulled the struts out.


Both struts mounts appear to be seated roughly the into the strut housing in the body, it just looks like the drivers side strut mount has collapsed into itself already.
Yes I have taken it for a shakedown run to see if the passenger side would seat itself higher after the suspension was cycled a few times but made no difference.
Has the drivers side strut mount failed already??????????
Should I pull it off & try for warranty?
What is involved in changing over to the later style strut mounts? would I need to change the actual struts & springs or just the mounting hardware from the top of the spring onwards.
Sorry for the long post , but thought it might save a few questions going back & forth.
Hope you guys can help.......
Cheers
Brendan
Comment