Above Forum Ad

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Volkswagen doesn't swap signal/wiper levers?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #16
    Originally posted by Marakai View Post
    So, it's 10 o'clock = first, 2 o'clock = second, 4 o'clock = third and so on?
    There is no standard layout for a manual transmission (and your pattern sounds bizarre)

    A VW 6 speed would be 10 oclock, 8 oclock, 12 oclock, 6 oclock, 2 oclock, 4 oclock, R is push down, left & up
    Last edited by brad; 16-12-2012, 11:50 AM.
    carandimage The place where Off-Topic is On-Topic
    I used to think I was anal-retentive until I started getting involved in car forums

    Comment


    • #17
      I find I muck it up more in our two Japanese cars, than I do in my Polo.

      Same goes for selecting reverse.
      '07 Transporter 1.9 TDI
      '01 Beetle 2.0

      Comment


      • #18
        On automatic transmissions, the selector pattern was part of an ADR, however I understand as it has now become industry standard the ADR has been withdrawn.

        P R N D

        After D, you can have additional forward gear options.

        To go from Drive to Reverse, you must go through Neutral, and Park cannot be adjacent to Neutral or any forward gears.
        --

        Comment


        • #19
          Originally posted by Umai Naa!! View Post
          As the manufacturer intended it.
          Hehe, yeah, was just trying to imagine what would happen if they'd gone by some "first and second are closest to driver, then 3/4, then 5/6 - and who the hell knows where reverse is". Sooooo many engine parts coming loose!

          Comment


          • #20
            Originally posted by brad View Post
            There is no standard layout for a manual transmission (and your pattern sounds bizarre)

            A VW 6 speed would be 10 oclock, 8 oclock, 12 oclock, 6 oclock, 2 oclock, 4 oclock, R is push down, left & up

            Argh, that's because I was half-way out of the door when I wrote it. Re-reading it, I myself went WTF? Not even my very first car, a Citroen 2 CV was that screwed up. I now haven't the slightest idea what I was visualising when I typed that in! Good lord!

            Of course, it's as you said and my curiosity was about whether it would be mirrored to reflect some concept based on driver proximity - so 2 o'clock, 4 o'clock, noon, 6, 10, 8 and R push-down and RIGHT & up.

            PS: just remembered what the 2CV actually had and something in my hindbrain must have linked to that: 8 o'clock, noon, 6 o'clock, 2 o'clock - and reverse was hard far-shift to right then up. Really!

            Comment


            • #21
              Originally posted by wai View Post
              On automatic transmissions, the selector pattern was part of an ADR, however I understand as it has now become industry standard the ADR has been withdrawn.

              P R N D

              After D, you can have additional forward gear options.

              To go from Drive to Reverse, you must go through Neutral, and Park cannot be adjacent to Neutral or any forward gears.
              What would they do pn a nwe jag with the dial?

              The original reason for swapping indicator sides was so that you can change gear and indicate at the same time. Back in the early days (way before I was born), I understand that changing gears was a little harder than it is these days (even in a manual) so you spent quite a lot of time with your hand on the gear lever. Not so much of a problem these days, what with synchros on your gears and everything....

              We have both. I just seem to remember and use the correct hand when driving. It's no big issue.

              Comment


              • #22
                Yep, all euro cars that I have driven had then in the euro arrangement. even a holden barina back in 2000 was on the left.

                I had a Nissan pulsar and gti for a while and always could just switch over without incorrect wiping/indicating.

                Comment


                • #23
                  Oz assembled Vectras also retained the Euro stalk positioning. Holden at the time said the translation was $250k+ in development it didn't want to spend.
                  Brilliant Silver Octavia Scout 2010

                  Comment


                  • #24
                    Volkswagen doesn't swap signal/wiper levers?

                    My wife and I have my Passat and her Mazda2. Occasionally we'll flick the wrong lever, usually the first time only in whichever car we're driving.

                    I used to have a Euro Barina and a VZ panel van, again swapping between the two of them without any hassles, as well as other various family members' cars which swapped sides throughout.

                    And just to add to the mix, I was also in the fire brigade so fairly regularly went from whichever of my cars to any one of three or four fire trucks, with different gear shift patterns, wiper/indicator levers, not to mention siren/light controls and just shifting from a car to a 12-15 tonne truck....
                    Last edited by passatpout; 17-12-2012, 10:20 AM.
                    MY08 Passat 2.0 TDI Wagon
                    Trialling golf ball aerodynamics theory - random pattern, administered about 1550 on Christmas Day, 2011.

                    Comment


                    • #25
                      Originally posted by Marakai View Post
                      Of course, it's as you said and my curiosity was about whether it would be mirrored to reflect some concept based on driver proximity - so 2 o'clock, 4 o'clock, noon, 6, 10, 8 and R push-down and RIGHT & up.

                      PS: just remembered what the 2CV actually had and something in my hindbrain must have linked to that: 8 o'clock, noon, 6 o'clock, 2 o'clock - and reverse was hard far-shift to right then up. Really!
                      Then there was the Columbo car (Pugeot 203 I think) that had a completely different column shift pattern. Also, on automatics, you have the Dodge (and others) that had press button controls rather than a floor or column shifter. My brother had an earlier Honda CRV that had a column mountes selector and it was very dangerous as it did not take much of a bump to cause the lever to change into neutral. Many early column shifters required you to pull the lever towards you before it would move out of the selected position to avoid this, but not the Honda.

                      It is quite a minefield and quite incredible that despite all the different shift patterns and systems, the foot pedals have remained the same.
                      --

                      Comment


                      • #26
                        AUS delivery EURO cars with left hand indicators is old news, decades old. I recall one of my Uncles Volvo back in the late 70's had indictors on the left so that was my first experience of Euro left hand indicators. Not long after that my parents got their first Mercedes & ofcourse it too had left hand indicators.

                        Holden ZC Vectra's produced in the UK (2002-2004) for Australian delivery had the indicator on the right hand side. Later production (2004/5-2007) came from Germany & I believe still had the indicator on the right.
                        * MY12 B7 Passat V6 4-motion Highline wagon....
                        * Sport pack (Kansas wheels) - Active cruise City EB - Driver Assist Vis pack - Auto tailgate - Candy White with dark tint.

                        Comment


                        • #27
                          Just to confuse things even more, how about motorcycle side stands and centre stands, they all operate from the left of the motorcycle even where you drive on the right hand side of the road.

                          So things happen and we as users have to generally accept it.
                          --

                          Comment


                          • #28
                            Originally posted by wai View Post
                            Just to confuse things even more, how about motorcycle side stands and centre stands, they all operate from the left of the motorcycle even where you drive on the right hand side of the road.

                            So things happen and we as users have to generally accept it.
                            Now what should happen is that we just switch to right hand driving!

                            a) Sweden did it successfully as did, IIRC, Okinawa
                            b) Car makers would save millions and millions not having to design and produce for LHS/RHS
                            c) You wouldn't even notice on your average Australian freeway because everybody is *already* driving on the right, going 90, while I pass the mongrels on the left! :-P

                            Comment


                            • #29
                              Originally posted by Marakai View Post
                              Now what should happen is that we just switch to right hand driving!

                              a) Sweden did it successfully as did, IIRC, Okinawa
                              However, steering wheels were already on the left in Sweden, and there were about a million cars registered in 1967. Back in 1971 Oz had 4 million cars registered, and now has around 16.5 million. Given the associated infrastructure changes needed, the change won't happen unless India, Japan and the UK change as well, leaving us stranded with RHD.
                              Brilliant Silver Octavia Scout 2010

                              Comment


                              • #30


                                Originally posted by Marakai View Post
                                c) You wouldn't even notice on your average Australian freeway because everybody is *already* driving on the right, going 90, while I pass the mongrels on the left! :-P

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X