Above Forum Ad

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Jeremy clarksons 2004 sunday times review of the mk5 gti

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Jeremy clarksons 2004 sunday times review of the mk5 gti

    Came across this old review and thought it was worth rehashing as many may not have had the chance to read it.

    From The Sunday Times
    December 26, 2004
    Volkswagen Golf GTI
    Drive away those Guardian blues
    Jeremy Clarkson
    In a recent Guardian article about traffic congestion, it was claimed that if every vehicle in Britain were parked nose to tail, the resultant snake would fill a 12-lane motorway all the way from Birmingham to Beijing. Well I’ve done the maths, and it’s true. But then it’s also true that if you laid all the words in The Guardian’s monstrous 16-page feature end to end, they’d stretch from my desk all the way to the wastepaper bin in the kitchen.

    And I don’t see the point, frankly. We know the roads are full of cars in the same way that space is full of stars, and the countryside is full of mud. I just don’t know what I’m supposed to do about it.

    Most of the piece was centred around a handful of London dwellers who explained that they spend anything up to four or five hours a day in traffic, which is nearly enough time to get through a Guardian article explaining how long it takes London dwellers to get to work in a morning.

    But look. The traffic is very bad in London for two reasons. First of all, this is one of the most wondrous cities in the world, so naturally lots of people want to live there. And second, it’s run by a bunch of Guardianistas who spend the morning reading about traffic congestion and the afternoon making it worse with idiotic parking regulations and traffic-light phasing from chapter one of a book called How To Be a Lunatic.

    Who cares, though? People in London have a choice. Obviously they can’t use a bus because, as Margaret Thatcher famously said: “Any man over the age of 30 who finds himself on a bus may count himself a failure.” But they can take a cab, or a train, or the Tube, or a rickshaw, or a horse.

    Elsewhere in Britain, however — and contrary to the teachings of The Guardian, most of us do actually live elsewhere in Britain — there is no choice. Take Oxford, for example. Because the local council is obsessed with any form of transport, so long as it isn’t a car, it has created special lanes for just about everything else.

    Were the earth to be in the path of a giant meteorite, Oxford’s frizzy-headed burghers would give it priority on the city’s roundabouts on the basis that it wasn’t burning fossil fuels.

    So as a result you sit in your car, stationary, watching completely empty buses that no one wants to use making sonic booms as they fly by at twice the speed of sound.

    But, as I said, what are we supposed to do about it? Stand as a councillor? You must be joking. Councils are run by people who are useless or mad, and by standing against them you’re demonstrating that you’re rational. Which counts you out. I suppose you could ride into town on a cow — they’d like that — but I think I have a better suggestion. Buy a Golf GTI.

    Twenty-five years ago, before the Madness of King Tony descended on the land like a big, itchy blanket, the first Golf GTI was very much the right car at the right time. Engineers and keen drivers will tell you that it was the first car to successfully combine the thrills of a sports car with the practicality of a hatchback, and this was unquestionably true, but there was an important social issue too.

    It was launched at pretty well the precise moment when Britain was freed from the shackles of union power and set off on the golden road to the riches we enjoy today. We needed something discreet for those first tentative steps out of the darkness, and the GTI, which was fast,without being flash, ticked all the right boxes. As a result VW sold more GTIs in Britain than anywhere else in the world.

    Think of it as a chrysalis. A midpoint between the dreary caterpillar of the 1970s and the flamboyant butterfly bling-ness we see today. It was a great car. In fact, I voted for it as the greatest car of the 20th century.

    Sadly, though, over the years the Golf became fat and old to the point where the Mark 4 version was slower from 0 to 60 than the automatic version of Rover’s ancient 25. And the GTI badge lost its magic, too, becoming synonymous with Blackbird Leys and sky-high insurance premiums.

    As a result the family looking for a car with a bit of presence went off and bought a big off-roader instead. And the young and single bought a two-seater sports car which, as the hot hatch died, came back to life. Great. But on today’s overcrowded roads neither type of car works terribly well. Which brings us back to the new GTI.

    There are those who say the latest version recaptures the magic of the 1976 original, but that’s not true. It’s twice as heavy and twice as luxurious, for a kick-off. It even has power steering, for heaven’s sake. But what it does do, once again, is capture the mood of the moment perfectly.

    Let’s be honest, your enormous off-roader may make you feel like the king of the road, but it is hard to park, and you do spend an awful lot of time filling it up with fuel at £70 a pop. And do you need all that space? Really? Because the Golf has five seats as well, you know, which is just as many as you have in your Range Rover or BMW X5.

    Then there’s this bothersome footballing business. It may be acceptable for some 20-year-old thicko on £70,000 a week to run around in something vulgar and ostentatious, but do you want people to think you’re Rio Ferdinand? So why have that Bentley Continental then? Because it’s fast? Okay, well I’ll make a bet. You can choose any route, anywhere in Britain, and I’ll cover it at least as quickly in a GTI. I’ll have more fun, too.

    And here’s the rub. The Guardian may like us to believe that Britain is completely gridlocked, but it’s not. If I were to leave my house right now I could be doing 100mph in as long as it takes the car to accelerate to that speed.

    I am surrounded by hundreds of miles of road that have never seen a traffic jam; roads that are unpoliced and miles from children playing ball. It’s the stuff of car ads round here. It’s wonderful.

    Sure, you occasionally encounter a Rover with a Christian fish on the back, doing 16mph, and this is where the torque of the new GTI’s 2 litre engine comes in. You don’t even need to drop out of sixth. Such is the grunt that if you put your foot down the little car can be past the Christian on even the shortest straight.

    Then you have the bends. Maybe when it’s greasy there isn’t as much grip from the driven front wheels as you’d expect, but you really have to be flying to notice. And when you are flying, being hugged by quite the most exquisite seats I’ve ever found in a car, you’re having too much fun to care. As a driver’s car, then, the new GTI is just fantastic.

    Then you’re in London, where it’s small enough to fit in even the tightest of Soho’s multi-storey car parks. Then you’re on the motorway, where it’s quiet and refined. And then you’re in a jam watching the television, or making calls on the hands-free. And then you’re at the supermarket with the rear seats folded down, jamming a Christmas tree in the back. And then you’re in an accident with airbags leaping out of every flat surface.

    As is the way with the old Golf, this new one is never caught out socially, or on the road. It works outside the best restaurant in town and it works when it’s minus seven. It works if you’re a Guardian reader and it works if you take The Times. It’s not chav. It’s not bling. And with prices starting at less than £20,000 it’s not that expensive, either.

    It’s hard, really, to think of any car that does anything like as much, anything like as well.

    Vital statistics

    Model Volkswagen Golf GTI
    Engine type Four-cylinder, 1984cc turbo
    Power 197bhp @ 5100rpm
    Torque 207 lb ft @ 1800rpm
    Transmission Six-speed manual front-wheel drive
    Fuel 35.3mpg (combined)
    CO2 192g/km
    Acceleration 0-62mph: 6.9sec
    Top speed 145mph
    Price £19,995
    Rating 4/5
    Verdict Simply the most complete car on the road
    Print

  • #2
    Thanks for putting that up - never read it before.
    He reused bits of it in his Top Gear review of the car.

    Comment


    • #3
      The article was a review on the GTI?


      .:R32 | GIAC | HALDEX II | MILLTEK | BMC | WHITELINE | A-ROTORS | HAWK

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by Nathan_B View Post
        The article was a review on the GTI?
        Was thinking the same thing. Clarkson pisses me off, he just talks too much crap and never actually reviews anything properly. I rarely watch TG now, I prefer 5th gear because they actually review cars.
        MKV GTI

        Comment


        • #5
          Worst Review ever.

          For those that would like a proper decent driving review of the Mk V GTI, try this one from EVO.co.uk - the best car mag in the world I reckon:
          --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

          Expectations are high for the new GTI, and we were the first to drive it on UK roads

          The Golf GTI is back - bold, unambiguous and, by the the looks of the spec, equipped to take on the leading fast hatches. It's about time. There were four sporty Golfs in the mk4 line-up and none of them hit the nail on the head; not the limp 115bhp GTI, soul-less 150bhp 1.8T GTI, loping 170bhp V5 or the four-wheel-drive 237bhp V6 R32. The R32 was the pick of the bunch but a rather complex, heavy and expensive solution to making an entertaining Golf.

          The mk5 GTI is refreshingly focused, with front-wheel drive and a torquey, 197bhp 2-litre four-cylinder turbo petrol engine that should be a good match for the car's bulk. Volkswagen claims a top speed of 145mph and 0-62mph in 7.2sec.

          Finished in blood red, with generous honeycomb-pattern front grilles, black sills and darkened rear glass, the GTI looks the part, especially when it looms in the rear-view mirror. It's a measure of the Golf's ever-growing shadow that the tasty five-hole alloys fitted to our test car look small - at 17in diameter, they're not. Bigger 18s with even lower profile tyres will be offered for just £455, which looks mighty tempting, but you might want to stay your options-ticking hand until you've read this, the first drive of the GTI on notoriously demanding British A- and B-roads.

          Despite its generous proportions, the spacious new GTI makes you feel snug thanks to its excellent sports seats.
          Trimmed in plain grey cloth with tartan centre panels - a nod to the original GTI - they have deep side bolsters that hug you in all the right places. The leather-trimmed steering wheel is an ergonomic delight, too, its fat, sculpted rim offering a comfortable, positive grip, and it looks the part, too, with perforated sections and a flat lower edge. It adjusts for rake and reach, while the seat height can also be tuned, enabling a perfect driving position to be tailored. Completing the driver-oriented landscape are a chunky gearlever and a pair of fussily marked main dials.

          Anyone who has driven the 1.8-litre, 20-valve turbo engine - and there must be plenty of you because it has found a home in just about every sporty model in the VW, Audi, SEAT and Skoda ranges - won't be expecting much from the new 2-litre turbo unit. With 197bhp and 207lb ft of torque, this FSI engine isn't as potent as the 1.8T fitted to, say, the Seat Leon Cupra R, but in fact it's one of the GTI's best features. While the 1.8T is a bland, unexciting performer, the 2-litre direct injection FSI is stimulating and effervescent, a pleasant surprise given the turbo's delivery is capped to give linear torque between 1800-5000rpm.

          There's nothing linear about the delivery, though, and underpinning its strong, responsive performance is a genuinely engaging induction note. Somehow VW's engineers have given this turbo engine a normally-aspirated voice - a guttural, appealing bwarp that swells with bass on large, low-rev throttle openings and then gradually thins out to a keen bark that reaches a natural peak and suggests an upshift.

          Peak power arrives at an unusually low 5100rpm but, foot down, the tacho needle sweeps purposefully past this mark and is still doing good work at the 6500rpm redline. The growly note encourages you to go there and, if the need arises, the engine will go to 7000rpm before the limiter cuts in. The six ratios are well-spaced, while the shift action is crisp and positive.

          VW's engineers have seen no need for further strengthening of the Golf shell for its GTI role, though naturally the suspension - MacPherson struts up front with a multi-link rear - has been tweaked. The GTI sits 15mm lower, has stiffer anti-roll bars, shorter, stiffer springs and re-valved dampers.

          The variable-rate electro-hydraulic assisted steering feels worryingly light at car park speeds but soon takes on weight as the pace rises, while the chassis initially feels very stiff, especially laterally. There's a vaguely racecar-like feel to how the GTI moves. Yet there is suppleness, too, the edges of any road imperfections being softened quietly by the suspension, and there's fine body control over large bumps and dips.

          Still, attack a second gear corner and roll is firmly resisted. The Golf corners flat and secure and seems to distribute the cornering load between the front and rear evenly without any sense of the rear getting a little loose as you turn the nose in. You turn and the car simply settles comfortably into the corner, clean and calm.

          The steering isn't overburdened with feel but its weighting is spot-on, and when you feed in the power for the exit there are no writhings as the tyres - 225/45 Bridgestone Potenza RE050s - lay all 207lb ft on the road. It's impressive because although this rarely feels or sounds like a turbo engine, one of the tell-tales that it has a light-pressure blower is the very strong low-rev delivery.

          Another is a slight pause before it picks up after you've snapped the throttle open, so the fact that the front wheels remain undeflected when the torque floods in is confidence-inspiring. In the dry the ESP warning light rarely flickers, and VW's chassis engineers should be praised for allowing some slip and spin before it intervenes, which it does remarkably discreetly.

          It's easy to find yourself haring along at much more of a pace than you expect. The engine is very strong right through but especially in the low- and mid-ranges. At speed the ride soaks up everything a tricky road can throw at it, and there's so much cornering grip that, despite weighing a substantial 1328kg, the Golf can carry lots of speed through bends.

          In this respect it's quite Mini Cooper-ish. Back off sharply mid-turn and the rear does move, but not dramatically and certainly not with the feeling that it's adopting the three-wheel stance typical of Golf GTIs past. The brakes, like the steering, aren't the most feelsome but compared with the over-servoed pedal of previous generations, there's more resistance to lean against, so it's much easier to check-brake.

          If I had any concern it was that in the wet the GTI's roll-free stance would result in a lack of progression and feedback before a snappy breakaway. Happily for me, mid-afternoon the heavens opened and I was able to retrace my nadgety morning route. The ESP's loose leash means you can have modest wheelspin right through to the limiter if you lead-foot the GTI out of a wet junction in first gear, but also means that you have a little slip to play with in the corners, which can be useful for trimming your line. Fears of abrupt break-away proved unfounded, the Golf feeling remarkably secure and capable, though when the nose did power wide with the ESP switched off, recovery was a little slower than I'd have liked.

          There's no question that the mk5 GTI is an entertaining and appealing fast hatch, different to the best Golf GTIs that have gone before but deserving of a place alongside them. It feels like a driver's car, with its wonderfully supportive seats, chunky wheel and enthusiastically vocal and gutsy four-cylinder engine. Its flat-cornering chassis is sporty in a new way but the more you drive it, the more you appreciate how well it works, even on our uncompromising B-roads.

          Is the mk5 GTI good enough to beat the best in class and put Volkswagen back on top? That's a difficult question to answer because in scale and price (a fiver short of £20K) the Golf isn't a direct rival for feisty little funsters like the Clio Cup and Mini Cooper S. However, against bigger rivals like the bargain-priced Civic Type-R and Leon Cupra R, and the upcoming harder-edged version of the RenaultSport Megane, I'd fancy the Golf's chances.

          Champion or not, the great news is that the mk5 Golf GTI shows that Volkswagen hasn't forgotten how to make a characterful, capable and engaging fast hatch. The GTI is definitely back.

          Comment

          Working...
          X