Starter motor options for 2007 MY08 1.9 TDI BXE

[gle1234]

Looking at my options to repair or improve my starter - I've been told by my mechanic that it's "tired" and I didn't really want to hand over another $560 last time I had it serviced. What are my options?

1. Clean / recon current starter components per this video on YT (Starter motor repair VW Audi Skoda Seat 1.9tdi - BOSCH 0001125012 - YouTube).

• Will this help a 'tired' starter?
• I've read the brushes can wear out but I'm not sure what type of starter symptom this relates to.

2. Replacement.

• Bosch seems to be the recommended replacement.
• What is the difference between the 1.7kw and 2kw starter? I'm assuming the 2kw is an upgraded part? Does more power = better? The 2kw ones I've found run at around $500.

Apart from this I can't tell any other differences between these 3 starters on SparesBox.

1. 0 001 123 012 - $588 - No specs provided.
2. 0 001 123 014 - 1.7kw - $270
3. 0 001 123 036 - 2kw - $443

Thanks all

[gle1234]

Update: So I did a complete teardown, clean, regrease and reassemble. Really happy with the improvement in starting.

I used the following video to test starter operation, solenoid, internal contacts : How to test your starter motor & solenoid - Starter troubleshooting - YouTube.

The brushes are quite worn after 13 years, so I will order some and have them ready to go when needed.

Note for my 1.9 DSG starter - all of the nuts are is accessible from the top of the engine bay once you remove the airbox. No requirement to go under the car. Something I wasn't 100% clear on before starting the job.

Flywheel DIY Next.