I don't think the guys here are being overly negative when suggesting to go the GTI route. On every car forum I've been on over the years, there are many threads about boosting a NA engine and what it would take. Invariably it works out to be quite expensive, obviously due to things like rods and pistons being unsuitable in stock form and needing to be replaced, but secondarily from things like brake upgrades, clutch upgrades and sometimes gearbox work and custom driveshafts/diffs. I've even seen someone split a firewall due to running too much power through a chassis never designed for it.
You want something reliable, repairable, and something that when you sell it eventually isnt going to freak people out and have them not trust it. Quirky builds can be good, but you also limit your audience.
One thing I'll say is that I have never seen so many 'off the shelf tunes' as on the VW forums I've just joined (I'm new to the brand). What's with people not tuning their cars on a dyno/street like japanese cars? 'Chips' are traditionally conservative tunes and by nature are not optimized for individual engines, and I've never seen one recommended ever before. Yes dyno tuning costs money, but you'd be mad not to do it properly IMO, so don't think having to get a proper tune due to the unavailability of a 'chip' is negative.
At the end of the day its your money, and if it makes you happy, do it.
You want something reliable, repairable, and something that when you sell it eventually isnt going to freak people out and have them not trust it. Quirky builds can be good, but you also limit your audience.
One thing I'll say is that I have never seen so many 'off the shelf tunes' as on the VW forums I've just joined (I'm new to the brand). What's with people not tuning their cars on a dyno/street like japanese cars? 'Chips' are traditionally conservative tunes and by nature are not optimized for individual engines, and I've never seen one recommended ever before. Yes dyno tuning costs money, but you'd be mad not to do it properly IMO, so don't think having to get a proper tune due to the unavailability of a 'chip' is negative.
At the end of the day its your money, and if it makes you happy, do it.
Comment