Above Forum Ad

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

diesel and Aus politics dont mix... apparently

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • diesel and Aus politics dont mix... apparently

    Hi there fellow converts,

    thought i'd start a bit of a commentary on my take on the current situation in australia as far as energy and sustainability goes. It's something I'm passionate about, and i think its omething everyone should atleast be aware of, given the current world climate (climate in every sense of the word).

    As keen dieselers you guys are all automatically aware of the importance of fuel economy, or you would have petrol guzzlers... no offence ot the petrol heads either.

    I know some of you guys are into bio-fuel as well, which for me is very encouraging. My father has been making his own bio-d and running it in golfs and a 240D merc for almost 4 years i think it is now. having to drive 100km round trip to work each day means he's saving thousands per year on fuel, with an outlay in time and effort at home. but even then, the principal behind bio-d alone is enough for dad to make it, as it is carbon neutral and cleaner than dino-diesel.

    Some of you may have heard that ABG, the Australian Biodiesel Group, has recently brought in their new factory outside Brisbane. Unfortunately, they also announced that due to lack of support from federal and state governments, further plans to expand are not being considered at this time. They will instead turn theire focus to the US, which for all its current bad politics, is more supportive of biodiesel research than we are, apparrently.

    This is saddening news for me, as it shows that although there is significant industrial and commercial interest in building this sustainable energy infrastructure, there is clearly no political support for it.

    Even more discouraging are certain other aspects of the encumbant industrial commercial and political heads policies seeping down the the next generation of engineers and specialists, and the population as a whole:

    In the last week, as a member of Engineers Australia I have recieved invitations to tour the new coal loading facitly at Kooragang island, set to increase total output of the facility to 111 Mega tonnes/year (thats 111,000,000 tonnes exported); and to an information/promotion night for "the hybrid evolution", a seminar on the benefits of hybrid technology, and a toyota prius on display.

    given that both of these areas are, to my point of view, dead end roads to an unsustainable future, it seems annoying to me that separate industry orgainisations like IEAust are placing such positive wraps on these areas that I think i ought to be trying to think AROUND, and not WITH.

    Anyway, if anyone has some comments i'd love to hear what you guys all think.

    Cheers,

    Aydan
    '07 Touareg V6 TDI with air suspension
    '98 Mk3 Cabriolet 2.0 8V
    '99 A4 Quattro 1.8T

  • #2
    Tell me, is the government only expecting us biodiesel producers to pay 19c/l, or are they expecting the full 38c/l?
    That alone seems like enough reason to accuse the government of not encouraging the use of biofuels!
    Peugeot 306 XTDT 1.9 Turbo Intercooled Diesel

    1976 LS parts vehicle

    Used to have: Mk1 Swallowtail LS DIESEL!

    Comment


    • #3
      Perspective

      Let's get the biofuel thing into perspective.

      * It's great.
      * It's renewable.
      * It does wonderful things for your injection pump.
      * It's emissions are less.

      BUT:

      * It's taxable.
      * If you use waste it's a bugger to get clean.
      * If you use virgin it's not much cheaper than petrodiesel. (When I was about to start using it virgin poppy seed oil was 50c/L. Now it's in demand it's over $1.00. Canola is 20c/L more expensive. By the time I get it delivered or pick it up from 100km away it costs more than petrodiesel.)

      AND:

      If we were to grow enough oilseed crops in Oz to fuel our diesel fleet we would use ALL of our arable land to grow it plus have to import about the same again from overseas. If I was to put all of my farm under canola I could produce enough biodiesel to power my cars and tractors for 1 month of normal use.

      Not the answer I'm afraid. But, that not saying, "Don't keep on making biodiesel". Good on ya. Something is better than nothing. I still run canola through my fuel systems periodically 'cos I know it's good for them.

      Comment


      • #4
        Hmmmmm.

        I understand bio fuel should still be taxable, because in the end we are all road users and we gotta pay for the roads somehow.

        As far as i know, there is still the standard 38c/l excise on biodiesel. Added to this, there is no incentive for transport operators to use biodiesel, because they can no longer claim their diesel fuel rebate (12c/l) on biodiesel. If the government were to actively encourage the use of biofuels, surely more people would use them.

        Is this what you were getting at Ayden? Or was it more the idea of diesel in general.
        Peugeot 306 XTDT 1.9 Turbo Intercooled Diesel

        1976 LS parts vehicle

        Used to have: Mk1 Swallowtail LS DIESEL!

        Comment


        • #5
          In the EU there is a directive that 5.75% of all fuel use is to be biofuels by the year 2010 - that's only 4 years away.

          Biofuels are hitting the mainstream here. Recently in Germany i saw many service stations selling biodiesel at 99 euro cents/litre, normal petrodiesel is 1.30 euro/litre.

          In Sweden I noticed a Saab 95 with a small biopower badge on the back. Then I saw another, and another, and another... Also noticed many service stations selling E85, ie a mix of 85% ethanol 15% petrol. The Biopower version of the Saab 95 uses E85, and actually produces more power than the standard version. You also benefit from a lower annual tax, and are exempt from Stockholm's congestion tax charges. By the way, traffic in Stockholm is worse than in Sydney!

          In Finland biodiesel is becomming readily avaliable - and produced locally. A large plant is under construction - details at: http://www.nesteoil.com/default.asp?...1261,2357,2515

          This plant alone will provide around 15% of the country's diesel. Note that it's being built by a major OIL company... There are also several other plants for both biodiesel and ethanol under construction. The quest for self suffiency is certainly on in this part of the world!

          Comment


          • #6
            Great to hear the EU is getting their act together.

            15% biodiesel- that's pretty awesome!
            Peugeot 306 XTDT 1.9 Turbo Intercooled Diesel

            1976 LS parts vehicle

            Used to have: Mk1 Swallowtail LS DIESEL!

            Comment


            • #7
              Yeah and the New Saab running better on higher concentrations of ethanol is clever use of turbo technology and getting less engine knock than on petrol.

              The Swedes care about the environment and technology though.
              sigpic Camden GTI Performance. VW / AUDI Specialists
              All Mechanical Work, Log book Servicing, New and used Parts and Imports
              19-20/6 Badgally Road, Campbelltown, 2560
              02 4627 3072 or 0423 051737 www.camdengti.com

              Comment


              • #8
                have you heard about the 5 fuel volvo???
                VW: it aint just a car, its a way of life
                There are few things more satisfying in life than finding a solution to a problem and implementing it
                My Blog: tinkererstales.blogspot.com.au

                Comment


                • #9
                  just to answer a few questions...

                  it was put to transport minister last year the question of tax, and his answer was along the lines of:

                  "small producers for private use only still have to pay 38c/l tax, but we dont really care if you dont pay it"

                  the taxation spokesperson at the time said:

                  "everybody will pay 38c/l tax"

                  - take from that what you will.

                  now the question of oil:

                  there is a great deal of misinformation going about about the amount of land needed to grow oilseed crops, etc. calculations about oilseed growing take into consideration current fuel useage rates - not target rates.

                  heres some important things to think about:

                  > using biodiesel (and ethanol) is not the answer to all our problems. however it is the answer to some of them - heavy moving, industry, country people need to drive a long way etc...
                  > if we plan to exist for the next thousand years we need to be prepared, and indeed, welcome some change in how we think about, and the way we utilise resources such as waste oil and biomass.
                  > energy sources will need to be de-centralised and become area specific if renewables are to be successful
                  '07 Touareg V6 TDI with air suspension
                  '98 Mk3 Cabriolet 2.0 8V
                  '99 A4 Quattro 1.8T

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    An interesting thought experiment i did for one of my tech electives.

                    From my moderate knowledge of canola in the riverina region of NSW,

                    Avg yield= 1.5t/ha

                    Avg oil content: 35%

                    =0.525tonnes of oil per ha.
                    = about 570l of oil

                    now, if my diesel golf does the claimed 5.5l/100km, i should be able to travel 10300km on one hectare of canola.

                    Obviously this is greatly simplified, because the methanol is not factored in, nor is the power to plant, harvest, and press the canola, but it's a pretty cool thought!

                    I think for the amount of oil i am using, Mr Howard can go and get F%^&*d.
                    Peugeot 306 XTDT 1.9 Turbo Intercooled Diesel

                    1976 LS parts vehicle

                    Used to have: Mk1 Swallowtail LS DIESEL!

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by smithy010
                      I think for the amount of oil i am using, Mr Howard can go and get F%^&*d.
                      Hoorah, well said
                      sigpic Camden GTI Performance. VW / AUDI Specialists
                      All Mechanical Work, Log book Servicing, New and used Parts and Imports
                      19-20/6 Badgally Road, Campbelltown, 2560
                      02 4627 3072 or 0423 051737 www.camdengti.com

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Good on you Ayden for starting this thread.

                        The way we use energy must change if we are to survive as a civilisation as well as advances in technology and use of renewable energy sources such as biodiesel. I cant wait for a carbon price signal to be introduced (carbon trading/credits/tax) so there is a true cost of fossil fuels passed onto the consumer. That is when BD and other renewables will have the price advantage that is inherent to them and they deserve. Low emission coal will also be very important if they can make it work. Maybe then we will use energy with respect.
                        Wont happen with our fearless (blind) leader at the helm
                        Beige 79 Mk1 GLD White 76 Mk1 LS 3 door
                        White 68 Alfa 1750 Berlina Champagne 91 Alfa 75
                        Red 09 9N3 Polo TDI White 2010 Skoda Octavia Combi TDI

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Cost of a crop

                          Originally posted by smithy010

                          Obviously this is greatly simplified, because the methanol is not factored in, nor is the power to plant, harvest
                          As a guide, farmers generally work on the basis that it costs about half of the yield price to grow the crop. This of course doesn't include labour which is a considerable part of the real cost of producing the crop. If you like, this is the farmer's "wages".
                          So, by the time you include:

                          * seed
                          * fertiliser
                          * irrigation
                          * machinery costs (maintenance, interest etc)
                          * diesel
                          * interest on the land used
                          * wages of farm hands (you just can't do it all yourself!)
                          * pesticides (believe me...brassicas attract them all and without pesticides you just wouldn't have a crop)
                          * tax

                          Also remember that when the crop is cropped the ground has to be reworked (diesel, implements etc, etc)

                          ****** And of course... you can only plant the brassica every 4 to 5 years so if you have say 100ha of arable land only 25 can be under brassicas in any year.*******

                          You guys getting my drift?? When we say that if all of the arable land in Oz was used to cultivate oil seed we're really only talking about 1/5 to 1/4... and... the farmer has to make a profit or he starves.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            I'm with Brackie on this one especially since he's though of everything in my argument except the one other thing that we don't have enough of at the moment.....water.

                            Simply because of production constraints and demand, biodiesel will only ever be a portion of the answer.

                            Diesel in itself is not the only answer either given that it is the most polluting of the common automotive fuels in terms of particulates...to control particulates adds significantly to the cost of the vehicle in both emmision control tech and engine management tech.

                            The 'answer' (such as it is) is to source our automotive energy supplies from the widest range of fossil and sustainable sources that we can find....natural gas, LPG, methane, hydrogen, fossil oil, ethanol, plant oils, electricity etc etc etc....and to use only what we need rather than whatever we'd like.....

                            Wedding ourselves to one fuel over another becuase we percieve it to be better when all in all it is just another alternative is just as blind as our gargantuan (and futile) desire for fossil oil.

                            Incidentally, when I can, I've taken to using the biodiesel blend produced by South Australian Farmers Fuel http://www.farmersfuel.com.au/PremiumDiesel.html It is quite nice stuff. The Transporter enjoys the drink and seems to sip very nicely at it too.
                            FF are also moving towards the wide distribution of biodiesel too http://www.farmersfuel.com.au/Biodiesel.html

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by gldgti
                              > > energy sources will need to be de-centralised and become area specific if renewables are to be successful
                              The precise OPPOSITE of capitalism. The precise OPPOSITE of the oil companies whole charter of ideals. An oil company is one person who says the hole in the ground is theirs and uses it as gods wallet. With unimaginable profits of course they will work against all alternatives. They might be greedy they are probably immoral, but one thing you can be absolutley certian of, they aren't stupid. pick up a 100 year old newspaper and read the letters to the editor, they are word for word precisely what you are saying here. mask the dates on the paper, and you cannot pick which 'oil crisis' it was. it's an old game with the same players and the same gameplay the only thing new is you and your generation.

                              Originally posted by gldgti
                              > if we plan to exist for the next thousand years we need to
                              Will never happen. 6 billion, in fact anything billion for humans is a plague, and nature is going to do what it always does with all plagues. Correct it. We will be wiped out by nature itself, and it won't take 1000 years. I absolutley doubt it would take 100. I wouldn't be surprised AT ALL if I see it happen on the news myself.(I hope to be in the wilderness at the time)

                              Originally posted by Seano
                              Incidentally, when I can, I've taken to using the biodiesel blend produced by South Australian Farmers Fuel http://www.farmersfuel.com.au/PremiumDiesel.html
                              Want to borrow my crystal ball? in a few years the oil companies will drop the price of pump diesel to put this and all the companies like it out of business.

                              Originally posted by smithy010
                              Obviously this is greatly simplified, because the methanol is not factored in, nor is the power to plant, harvest, and press the canola, but it's a pretty cool thought!
                              Canola doesn't need processing, my Mk1 Diesel has a tank full of the stuff and so far so good, driven like 20 times getting the blueslip arranged and no problems, same as diesel. I am making parts so it can use waste oil.
                              alternate energy vw enthusiast....and general crackpot

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X